Towns in the Great Desert (7)

September 12, 2013

by Peter Boyle

from Southerly Journal

Poem is here

I can’t access every section of this sequence, so I’m only guessing at its overall gist. On the strength of (7) alone though, I can’t make it fit the theme of ‘The Political Imagination’. Imagination is everywhere, sure – the poem is about the phantasmagoria we create out of the sleep of reason, & what that says about the struggle to understand our own desolation. In titling the sequence ‘Towns of the Great Desert’, a connection is made to an inland sea of particularly Australian depression. But I don’t see this as a political metaphor, & I’m generally down with the idea that most to all poems are political. This is a good lyric poem.

It’s interesting to contrast the tone of this poem relative to the previous poem I looked at. ‘To drag the saints back’ was addressed to the you who might be about to attempt something emotionally momentous. Boyle’s poem wants to help us all “navigate” towards a “quiet core”, or a space for the genuine contemplation of our own impermanence. The poem as a GPS for our soul, if the GPS was low on batteries.

Note e.g. the diffidence in the directions being given. The first line is exhausted, teenage, ‘are we there yet’ in its suggestion that this is pretty hard work relative to the ease of above-ground life: “There are so many steps you must navigate”. When “sleep” finally comes, the similes are negligible and exhausted: “like a beautiful plant”. Things will happen when  you arrive that “you can’t understand”. The spectacle is overwhelming, crowded: “All that moss”. The best the poet can surmise is that this is a “small inkling of how it is / when life closes over”. “Inkling” is a noun I don’t tend to associate with poetry as much as I do with biography or interview journalism: today, the PM gave us a small inkling into his thinking on Syria. The poem might be about depression, but it’s also about how hard it is to write about depression.

What you note as a result is a borrowing of motifs. If Arnie in Total Recall describes his dream girl as demure & athletic, the poet’s version of introspection is after Goya and Tolkein. Note the Gimli figure emerging with a guidebook to construct a lost Dwarven mine(d)-city. Note the “monsters [that] keep peeling off you / like self-generating wallpaper”, and how they are like the owls rising out of Goya’s back. Maybe the point here is that reason doesn’t do well with sunlessness; it tries to fill the dark with influences & fantasy. Which in turn conjures Pound in Pisa, trying repeatedly to convince himself that he still lives in a world where it might be possible “to build the city of Dioce whose terraces are the colour of stars”.

With the failure of reason to recite the right “steps” towards contemplation, ‘pure’ poetry takes over with a veering towards Imagism (“Raw puddle / of a lone waterdrop”), and Blakean cosmos-revelation: open your hand (“OPEN YOUR MIND”) slowly away from the need to “navigate” & note that we are all accidental atoms. You have arrived at your destination, being Modernism.


To Drag the Saints back from Heaven

August 28, 2013

by Anne Elvey

from Meanjin

Poem is here.

This is a mother-god’s instruction manual (“To drag the Saints back, do the following”) to helping & loving someone through the five stages (stanzas) of grief or withdrawal or illness. If the steps in this process are familiar to you, the poem says, you are become empathy’s or charity’s omniscience. Charity in the Corinthians sense of selfless assistance, or what Pound was drawn to laud when one of the guards at Pisa set him up a writing desk & slipped him something for a UTI (sorry for the formatting):

and Mr Edwards superb green and brown

in ward No 4 a jacent benignity,

of the Baluba mask: “doan you tell no one

I made you that table”

methenamine eases the urine

and the greatest is charity

to be found among those who have not observed

regulations

Denial

This stage begets unpredictability. “You need to know you cannot count on this”. There is the hyperactivity of trying to relocate your existential codex – “busy / learning the names of things”. There is the paradox in attending celebrations held in your own honour, in wishing to have your own achievements retold to you in a kind of ‘This Is Your Life’ mode of I-am-not-really-past-my-use-by-date delusion. The memory of my greatness is still alive. I might be born again.

Anger

Don’t bug the new inpatient staring deep into the eye of the abyss. The whirlpool is tempting for its guarantee of eternal “day after day” Big Red Spot madness. The gift of the lover is in knowing nature & every repetitive weather event to be grace. You need to dig the rainy days.

Bargaining

Heaven is earth. I am in heaven & in thrall to what I dream to be the genius of its inhabitants (“frogs”). This self-delusion is such that we (as helpers) can communicate with them for the first time by making “your prayers amphibious”. You are in a coma, but I am talking to you. I know it.

Depression

is in the doe-eyed descent into your arms, promising sustenance. “To keep them”, like the pet that now accepts it needs to turn up on your doorstep, prepare a rudimentary & monastic menu, which is funny for its slightly hippie connotations.

Acceptance

The end stage is the acceptance of the notion of non-control. I cannot name everything. There are other wonders in the world, alternative “spikes of / blossom”. Salvation is in the indescribable miracles & mysteries of nature, & thus the necessity of metaphor: here, the weighty & welcoming bow of “the coastal banksia’s bent answer to a place”. With the final irony being that the banksia was named after the bloke who wanted to name & classify everything.


Burrow

July 20, 2013

by Margaret Ross

from Boston Review

Poem is here.

I don’t think this poem is substantial, in the sense that the idea it gets at – that we are indifferent to the hidden depths of nature – isn’t groundbreaking. The superficiality / depth divide is the chief analytical conceit of high school English. But poems were never meant to be treatises. What is good about this poem is its really weird tonal progression, in that it charts the burrowing of a nutty professor-poet from scientific proposition to poetic abstraction.

The poem opens with an hypothesis. Let us propose, the poem says, that “grass explains what is invisible / beneath it”, and go from there. Poems don’t often introduce the possibility of their own metaphors – metaphors are possibilities in & of themselves. Unless you’re being self-conscious or meta. This poem becomes powerful because it’s meta, because the poet grows into the metaphor hesitantly proposed at the start of the poem.

As well as the hypothesis introduced by “if”, much of the language in the first two thirds of the poem just sounds science-y. “Each blade in shorthand / spells a corresponding channel / cut”. You don’t see words like “corresponding” very often in poetry. Poems are generally meant to let readers do their own corresponding. I’m reminded of Leonard Bernstein’s Norton lectures, when he spends 20 minutes explaining why the phrase “Juliet is the sun” is poetic – because deliberate syntactical and grammatical absence is at the heart of metaphor. Look as well at “continuing below / the dirt’s horizon”. The poet doesn’t need to tell us this. The image of the “corresponding channel / cut” was enough to summon the idea of what lies beneath. Poems tend to represent the tip of the iceberg, not the exposition of the whole thing. Unless you’re Milton circa Paradise Lost, who begins with “Of” instead of “If”:

                Of Mans First Disobedience, and the Fruit
                Of that Forbidden Tree, whose mortal taste
                Brought Death into the World, and all our woe,
                With loss of Eden, till one greater Man
                Restore us, and regain the blissful Seat,
                Sing Heav’nly Muse…

But he was planning something pretty expansive.

Look as well at the awkwardness of “the muscles underground / exceed their animals”. With the subversion of natural laws comes descriptive difficulty. The physical expectations of an “animal” can be exceeded in certain circumstances. This calls for further scientific citations from nature, which the poet promptly provides: “as phosphenes flare…”, “as pygmy mice / that nightly set”.

I think it’s at this point that the science-poet becomes convinced enough on the facts of her own motif to ‘become poet’. Thus the flourishes of the poem’s last three lines. In the abstractness of their connection to the “underground”, the list of above-ground enemies in stanzas eight and nine are poetic – they demand thought from their reader as to their connotative relevance. Yes, when I think about it, the daily passing of our “shadow” and “shifting / surface light” does display a certain mindlessness about what is subterranean. The sprawling “expanse” of our cities blinds us to the life in every “flimsy / arrow” of grass. We are each carried along like cast-off feathers & “fur” on the “breeze” of time. We ought to own up to our indifference to the fact “burrow” is a verb as well as a noun.

The unanswered question is whether such interpretation is generous. Was the poet conscious of ‘tonal progression’ as a motif in and of itself? Or is the poem more a postmodern record of our own non-confidence in poetic devices, an artifact of our present-day timidity towards metaphor & glory?


Courtly Love

July 3, 2013

by Fiona Hile

from Cordite no.42

Poem is here.

This poem is against the idea of a poet / kind of poetics that is in courtly love with itself, at least to the point where it can auto-fellate “itself to the bone”. It variously has a crack at post-Romantic, post-passionate anecdotal lyricism, John Tranter’s doctoral thesis, egotistic poetic exposition, & Lehman & Gray’s Australian Poetry Since 1788 anthology.

One of the big issues Hile has with the type of poet / poetry she’s describing here is that it wants to have its post-aniseed cake & contextualise / analyse / historicise the shit out of it too. It wants to be full of the “inflight metabolism” of streamed consciousness whilst allowing for the “hallucinatory parity” of meaning something. It wants to be courtly love-ish – “not quite revealing”, masks, silk handkerchiefs, a lot of sighing, as Simon Schama described the Tudor court – whilst constantly making note of the genius of its own devices. The suggestion by the end of this poem is that such self-conscious modes of performance are really just male modes of “negation”, of a desire for knowledge & power endlessly deferred.

I see the “shades” in the quaint scene conjured by the first line as both ghosts of old poets & poetics & also the happy ambiguities that accompany soft lyricism. The scene becomes cinematic & period-drama with that “cut-away” in the second line, but said cross-section also introduces the theme of a need to constantly go behind the scenes of expressive genius. “Palatine Uvula” is anatomical but also wonderfully aristocratic & Star Wars-ish. You need a patrician instrument if you’re to score an invite to the “dance”, the “catalogue of all catalogues” (Grey & Lehman’s anthology), which includes Tranter’s Lufthansa.

Such inclusion (which shouldn’t be that much of a shock, given it’s anthologised all over the place) is “treachery” for those of us who love the interesting & aesthetically interrogative Alphabet Murders-era Tranter. What’s seen to be worse is his own “citational / liquidation”, a kind of self-notational selling out exemplified by his odd doctoral thesis. Said thesis is “indexed to the absence of its own gelatin” – the point being that the best thing about Tranter’s poetry & most good poetry is that it lacks gelatin or a centre that can hold. Who needs answers in the back, a “filing cabinet” of explanation, an excuse for your absence, a teacher’s manual?

The spirit of the “post-aniseed Romantics” was not in this but in constantly “revealing the thing / that offends”:

One night I settled Beauty on my knee and found her bitter. – And I insulted her…

                I abominate all trades. Professionals and workers, serfs to a man! Despicable…

                The beggar’s honesty distresses me. Criminals disgust me – men without balls.

& believing that “saying it all” was entirely possible until you realised horribly that it wasn’t. Which is what A Season in Hell is so much about – a kind of constant stopping & starting of an all-consuming, all-of-history project. Said spirit was the opposite of anecdotal observation & a forced “splintering” or fragmentation of same; the opposite of classifying or knowing your aesthetic to be raconteur-ish or troubador-ish. It was beyond the deliberateness of devices deployed to “summon the shiver” from readers; the poem was the shiver. It did not deliberately “connote” or denote anything.

As suggested, I think the end of the poem is about how the new big-notational & courtly lyric mode tends to be deployed by an “infinite / number of men” with their dicks out, like little commas (“the shape of punctuation”). Gathered together, their pants can bulge to the assonantal echoes of “fretworked birds”, & they can go all Arthur Miller-ish in the way they voice “Woman”, which is to have them blaming themselves for the mercurial necessity of their husband’s philandering:

John, I counted myself so plain, so poorly made, no honest love could come to me! Suspicion kissed you when I did; I never knew how I should say my love. It were a cold house I kept!

Like the other poem by Hile I’ve read on this blog, Courtly Love is about poetics & so might only interest those interested in different debates about poetic authenticity that have raged since approx 1800. I personally lose patience with poems about poetry pretty quick, though not when they’re brought off with this much elan & dash.


Hauptbahnhof

June 23, 2013

by Jo Langdon

from Mascara Literary Review, Issue 13

Poem is here.

This is a poem which tries to reconstruct love out of memory. For a short poem, it packs in much that is mercurial – subtle internal rhythmical resolutions, subtle changes in tense, a ‘hinge’ simile (the “snow- / glass sequence”) that is developed to represent what the poet is really after: for the orgasmic blurriness of great memories to become or to exceed reality.

I see the title (translated I think as ‘central station’) as functioning in a similar way to the train-station end of a black & white romance. The poet refuses to say goodbye to a great time & so runs alongside the steaming carriage, catching a more & more indistinct view of the love-object.

At the beginning of goodbye, things are still immediate & raw, or at least the poet is trying to make them so. “We” remain in the present tense, conversational, post-coital: “the light’s gone / strange”; has it gone strange for you? Time is not of the essence. The weirdness of an alpine winter landscape (relative to Geelong, where it says the poet lives) is worth noticing, as are pigeons.

The tense has shifted by the second stanza. In thinking of Vienna, the syntax starts becoming rudimentary, (“it was pigeons”). A disconnect between the present and the past is foreshadowed by the use of parentheses – the reality of Vienna “in the instant” is that our bodies “were filthy, grained”. I love “grained” as an adjective that gets at travel-grime. Particularly the stuff that builds up on your teeth.

The poet stops herself here, precisely at the point that ‘reality’ starts intruding on memory: “I want you to see it all” is a demand both to departed lover & to herself – stop remembering things with the windscreen wipers of hindsight. Join me in the “miniature” of compartmentalised impression & of ephemera, like what a snow-glass creates with each shake – a little vignette of good times which drifts somewhere in between permanence & disappearance. Like when you stare into a bright light and blink a few times.

Such is preferable as memory to what the penultimate stanza represents: the beginning of categorisation and identification (“not the tilting flowers, starry edelweiess”), and the garishness of Sound of Music springtime cliche (“bright air in singing hills”). That way means facing up to the ‘actual’ reality described in the final line – the train left the station a fair while ago, & the love-object wasn’t exactly looking back.


Fallen Woman

April 30, 2013

from Mascara Literary Review

by Ainslee Meredith

Poem is here.

In cinematic terms, this poem picks & establishes its geography expertly well. The setting is one of newly discovered nightmarish-ness – the “clearest night”, complete with “full moon”, that remains “still unlit”. The nightmare is not original: sin & guilt imparted on “Fallen Woman” by predatory man, the “right to choose” replaced by the need for permission in all experience (“I am clear to cross”).

It’s the total weirdness of the setting for this crossing-into-awareness that fascinates me. South Hero is a small town in Vermont. Per Google Maps, it appears to have a causeway. Whether said causeway is ever blocked off by “saltwater and snow-water” is beyond me, but does it matter? It’s all about evocation, and it works. The ‘fire-break’ you could see as flashing boom gates, sending little “patina torches up / like false churches” (a feeling for the falsity of the church’s imposition of sin on women informs the poem). The “patina torches” could similarly be the rusty, wobbly reflections of starlights in water. The idea evoked by the images is of terrible, freaky ceremony.

I have my doubts as to whether South Hero’s causeway is a “game / road”, but again the surrealism works as an expression of the protagonist’s confoundedness & disbelief with the situation she’s dealing with (basically, being stalked). She portrays her own worth now as prey & roadkill: “an antelope / hit to the side of the road”. Every approaching headlight is the glaring threat of “oncoming eyes”. This is now what it’s like to walk at night.

The poem’s dialogue is between friend & victim, & the pronouns are jumbled deliberately to suggest empathy; I will make this my experience as you tell me about it. Nobody else but me was watching “the telephone” when it lit up in the “unlit” night to tell me what happened (“Anna: a man followed me”). Even in the poetic process of trying to find the right metaphors for her predicament, the friend’s presence a phone call away is “a way to ascension”, a “hold on my head” – the thing importuning her to stand with her shoulders back, even though her natural reaction now is to walk “bent over under the full moon”.

As I’ve said, the final images of the poem are about a new need for permission & the need to keep a low profile in a world where weakness will be pounced upon. The “fall” from a kind of wanderlustful innocence represented here finds its fulfilment in a David Prater poem I read way earlier on this blog. The voice of Prater’s protagonist is pure anxiety as to appearances. Meredith’s poem is filled with superbly simple lines that depict the stage before anxiety, being breathless shock: “Anna: a man followed me / because I was alone and lost”. Why would a man follow me because I was alone and lost? Where does such a “because” come from in a man?

Prater’s coping mechanism is in the rhythmical recitation of a cynically street-smart self-consciousness. Meredith’s poem is about the horribleness of having to cross into that consciousness.


After seven long years underground

April 10, 2013

by Elizabeth Allen

from Jacket2

Poem is here.

The story & setting here is recognisable: the unexpected return of an estranged loved one. What makes this poetry instead of anecdote is an underlying drama played out with metaphor and tone and perspective and just language generally. The drama is that the poet has no idea how to deal with the situation she’s presented with as a poet. The poem wants to act “decisively”, but instead becomes an acknowledgment that there is only so much language and language-techniques can do to represent the “impossible knot” of this type of situation.

This is best understood by identifying the number of ways the poet (in a pretty short poem) attempts to represent what’s going on. First, note the cliche of the poem’s opening. The image-idea of an ‘underworld’ to which evildoers retreat & from whence they emerge is ancient. Cracking & flaking mascara is similarly ancient as a motif out of light-prose cool-lit. The sibling’s re-emergence is neither glamorous in reality nor in the way it’s initially represented. The poet knows she needs to do better.

Anthropomorphism is always a safe option: the sibling compared to stray cat, best to distinguish her from the upright domestic poet-goddess who suddenly starts talking as posh-like as Nigella: “You have been preparing a lentil salad and / perhaps this has brought her”. See also the list of lentil salad ingredients, which work to bring out the aroma of this reunification, but suggest to me more an effort to avoid the emotional reality of the situation (this seems especially so once the poet resorts to the “the bite and tang of salt and sugar”, which again reads as being deliberately mundane).

The most important ‘distancing’ device through the whole poem is the use of the second person, which confirms the poem as an exercise in emotional avoidance. Look at the word usage: “You have been preparing a lentil salad and / perhaps this has brought her”, “She is like the neighbour’s cat which sometimes / steals into your kitchen” – the language contributes to a kind of guessing-game condescension that helps the person-poet to skirt the issue.

The final half of the poem is where reality literally “cuts” in. The acknowledgment is that family is so “impossible” that the poet’s response to it (particularly through the first half of the poem) is about “tightening and unpicking it in your chest” – trying to rationalise & make metaphors of the experience, trying to ‘tighten’ up your own reactions by comparing your sibling to a stray, etc. Harshest reality is seen in the fact the only real weapon the poet has (in light of the failings of language to capture what’s going on) is “the metal bowl”, which she tries to wield “decisively, making it / count” in awkwardly enjambed & ineffective fashion.

Just under the surface of the poet’s attempts at representation is the white headache-noise of trauma and disbelief and the sense that she can’t really deal with this right now (“the buzzing radio of thoughts: cicadas screaming”). The reality is that the poet’s “muscle” (head and heart) is twitching with aesthetic exertion. As poet, she needs to be “more / than” – she needs to make anecdotal lyric-light of the situation, because this is what poets in their traditional roles are supposed to do. As person & sibling, she needs to be “less than” – she needs to serve and love the person she’s been trying unsuccessfully to press-gang into language.


the welt is fort island must blackberry you

March 21, 2013

by Justin Clemens

from Southerly Journal 72.2 – True Crime

Poem is here (probably won’t work on mobiles)

I think it’s easiest to understand this poem as a dialogue-drama of poetic-philosophical promise & disappointment. This is an ‘academic’ poem, but it’s never not-fun or completely conceptual. I’ll try to talk myself through it with the assistance of Wikipedia.

The dialogue is with a trumpet, for which you can read the poet’s creative better half. The trumpet’s been teetering on a solipsistic precipice for a while (“drinkin a great deal of retardateur”). The trumpet slips into a sleep of unreason that produces a Rimbaud-ish monster of “bad language battering”. I like the image of the poet-self “choking on his own sucked-back drivel”, because it works as extension of the trumpet metaphor – if you’ve ever played a brass instrument, they do tend to get a bit clogged with old saliva after a while. “Battering” also works for this reason (a ‘battered horn’).

So what does the trumpet’s “disturbed kinda slumber” entail? A resistance against accepting any “further applications” to join some universal “fugue” or harmonic “marketing ritual”. No more dull poems. You’re better off not joining the contrapuntal crowd & just waiting for their inevitable next anthology (“hard copy”) to come out. The best recommendation is towards a rupturing of this unison & of the senses (“brack! brack” vs ‘Holy! Holy!’).

The poet’s skeptical half is introduced here – this temptation towards a disturbance in the “fugue” force is “a door / that needs closing! Now!”. The antecedent for this commotion is identified in Romanticism: “Everything gaped, like a philosopher at the French Revolution”. Which is funny, because that’s exactly what poets & philosophers did when they heard that their dreams of disruption were set to become a social reality:

“Bliss was it in that dawn to be alive,

But to be young was very heaven!—Oh! times,

In which the meagre, stale, forbidding ways

Of custom, law, and statute, took at once

The attraction of a country in romance!”

Of course, the revolution didn’t work out, & early democratic dreams were undercut in time by subtle forces of surveillance & power & control (thus the panopticon). The trumpet has prepared for the kickback & is on a roll: relax, this revolution is of the cybernetic & meta kind. His movement is towards a matrix of self-reflexivity, a Skynet of aesthetics. The poet switches to weird sci-fi robot font to voice his “accordance” to same, even if such accordance is richly sardonic: his inclusion is nought but “making a new sticker for an irreplaceable mix-tape we can no longer play”.

The poet knows this is a pipedream of resuscitation for a Romanticised mode which has no real relevance in the modern day (a “mix-tape we can no longer play”), & which also goes against the kind of anti-hierarchical & anti-normativising ideals we are meant to espouse in the even more modern day (“happy to betray their alleged principles in order to retain priorities which are precisely about not wanting to retain priorities”).

He goes along for the “horde-drive” anyway, even if such experiments are so “meta” these days that the best they can do is promise to promise. The trumpet & poet’s eventual disappointment is “Zitterbegung”, which I don’t really get, but the fact he exclamatorises his disappointment at the “origins of me orifices” suggests their experiment was towards a kind of etymological tribalism, a stripping-back to language-basics & little molecules of meaning (which sounds a bit Poundian).

The poet’s point as the poem closes out is that our “stories” of experiment are always doomed to “end unhappily” these days because they exist to be undercut by the misery of understanding we now have of ourselves as living chemistry, as “trembling” star stuff. Why would we go after “zany hopefulness” when our pale blue dot could be knocked into “interstellar space at any time” (which could also be a reference to the fact Voyager 1 has or is just about to enter intergalactic space)? Perhaps it’s best that we bounce prejudices off one another as in a game of Pong & resign our “stories” to “stochastic electrodynamicists” who can plot every human disturbance as an “interaction” of atoms in a pure vaccuum (a “zero-point field”).

The ending of this dialogue doesn’t leave us with much hope as to the possibility of future dream-states of aesthetic inspiration, but the poem as a whole (and particularly the way I read the title) exemplifies how the communication of aesthetic & philosophical excitement is something that can’t ever really be taken away: the welt (has become) fort island (i.e. a metaphor, and the possibility of poetry), (I, the excitable trumpet) must blackberry you. The poem is what happened when the poet picked up the phone.


Day of a Seal, 1820

March 14, 2013

by Michelle Cahill

from Cordite 41: Transpacific

Poem is here.

The surface narrative of this poem is recognisable. The poem’s accomplishment is in the way the narrative is performed – with a sense of intelligent idiosyncrasy that is deeply true to history.

The narrative

The seal smells what’s in the air (“I sniff the kelp and bloodworms”) & knows trouble is coming in the form of fur & oil traders. The seal hides in the narrow of a rock & witnesses the slaughter. The poem ends with the seal doing what you do when you’re really trying to hide – make yourself as “weightless as feathers”, stop the too-loud beating of your own “arteries”, & grimly bear the “acidosis” that comes with terrified effort.

The performance

“Acidosis” is emblematic of the poem’s language generally. If this is a poem spoken by a seal in the first-person, we’re talking about a very intelligent & uppity seal. See e.g. his ready identification of “a half-caste”. See e.g. a word like “pelagic”. See e.g. the consistent stanza pattern, which suggests an orderliness that doesn’t really befit a scene of “slaughter sands”.

The seal’s account comes to read like the account of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle in talking about the Viking invasions at Lindisfarne – foreboding & unselfconsciously literary (“pelagic fish are vanishing”… “there were excessive whirlwinds, lightning storms, and fiery dragons were seen flying in the sky”). It almost seems unbecoming & ridiculous that a seal would be made to have this voice. I think the poet is making a point about the orderly intelligence that abounded pre-1788; she is also (possibly) referencing the totemism of indigenous religion which would have assumed the seal is me; I am the seal; the seal is experiencing this horribleness with as much disbelief but clarity as me.

Bill Gammage gives a good example of what I mean by this in The Biggest Estate on Earth. He notes how early settlers saw that indigenous populations regarded porpoises as “having been the ancient chiefs of the neighbourhood…who, they said, drove fish on shore for them”. The seal in this poem is very “ancient chief”. Porpoise & human had such an understanding they were often seen to fish “in consort” with one another. To quote an early coloniser at length:

‘As soon as the shoal of fish appeared in the offing some two or three of the blacks would advance to the water’s edge, and, striking the water with their spears as a signal to the porpoises to drive the fish into the bank – which signal the porpoises would instantly obey – the main body of blacks…would rush in with their towrows and dip up the fish’

Note thus the seal’s protest at being made to awkwardly whisk himself into an “eroded kerb”; this is a creature for whom awkwardness is as unheard of as the need to hide his “fur”. Hiding & self-consciousness are entirely unnatural; the idea of sheltering from human contact is an idea that comes with colonisation, that comes with new demands that disturb a working ecosystem.

This makes the coming darkness all the more confronting. The “first blow shocks”, it doesn’t kill; you can almost imagine the seal-victim looking up & realising, ‘This dude is actually for real’. “Black women”, who for thousands of years were allied to seal / porpoise as assistants in abundance, now “pile our skins / on spits for tobacco, for oil”. The seal is now a resource to all in a fledgling colonial economy. A few snatched birds are an added & basic bonus. As Robert Hughes pointed out in The Fatal Shore, the exploitation of this ecosystem was made easier by the fact many bird species were so tame & unused to human aggression that they could literally be snatched from the ground:

‘The Bird of Providence…tasted oily and fishy, somewhere between a penguin and a chicken. The birds had never seen men before…Once grounded, they were encumbered by their long planing wings…More than 170,000 of them were massacred in one three-month span, April to July 1790, an average of nearly four birds per person per day’

Although the poem concludes in quiet terror, it hints at a religious fatalism which is also partially true to what little I know of Dreamtime beliefs. That is, where the seal acknowledges “I cannot strike back”, part of this acceptance is anatomical (he’s got flippers for goodness sake), and (the bigger) part of it is spiritual. To quote again from Gammage, “few if any (indigenous peoples) troubled over the question others ask westerners: ‘Why do you have more than us?’ They knew why – the Dreaming made it so”. The poem ends in the agony of this acceptance.


Soon

March 6, 2013

by Tim Grey

from Mascara Literary Review (Issue 12)

Poem is here.

This is the type of poem Emily Dickinson would’ve written if she lived in commission flats. I like it because the word choices (particularly the verbs) enliven the idea of hermetic desperation. The title I read in the kind of context a kid would understand: mum, when can we go; when can we leave “the facility”? Soon. The poem is as much about its intergenerational female protagonist (looking out at both “Brougham” and “fairlane”) as it is about how too much “small privacy” will often make for “small language” & a timidity of representation.

For the speaker, the sun doesn’t shine. This late in the day, when (at least to me) it tends to look its best, it rather “transports its late sticks to that other”. This is a pretty troubled interpretation of sunlight. Nearing dusk is when I find big rays are most visible & near-horizontal; for the speaker, sunlight is just a “flat”bed truck carting around the lumber of light. The “bees” aren’t making love to flowers; they “plumb and phase”. They prod the depths of nectar like a mechanic checking your oil, and they do so in gradual, scientific stages.

Worst of all, they meddle with the transparency of the speaker’s window, & her efforts to metaphorise something erotic out of what she’s seeing (“the lip / of smell”… “part / spring is mouth in her small privacy”). Having gifted herself a “mouth”, we get the first really ‘human’ verb of the poem; she self-identifies as viewer & becomes Romantic-omniscient, if briefly: “she watches / girls float on the asphalt pause, pool between convent and / Brougham”. Her power is such that she can know what they “imagine” (their being “unseen”, which has a skerrick of envy about it; I know you know that everyone is looking at you, and I hate it, and I hate you).

This slippage into value judgment makes for a jolt of perspectival punishment, depicted by virtue of more nasty-sounding verbs: “iron fencing clots / and weaves”. The acceptance of her fencing-in sparks in turn an acknowledgment (an ‘admission’, literally) of where we are – “the facility”. The verbs that follow begin to hint at frustrated, musty self-eroticism (“fumbling”, “pressed against”, “wets”).

The odd thing out in this increasingly dirty-sounding sequence is the “shopping… on the bench” & the elevator, of which the speaker knows “every zone” (just like, if you live alone in a place long enough, you know the cadence of every creak & can hear someone getting home a mile off). The suggestion is to situate this consciousness in (possibly) modern day public housing. But then the poem is deliberately ambiguous as to its setting, the point being that Whitman was writing about this personality type back in the 19th century:

 

Twenty-eight years of womanly life, and all so lonesome….

 

She owns the fine house by the rise of the bank,

She hides handsome and richly drest aft the blinds of the window…

 

Where are you off to, lady? for I see you,

You splash in the water there, yet stay stock still in your room.

 

The difference being that ‘Soon’ is of a distinctly un-Whitmanian era when we tend to accept that our “small language” is constantly “fumbling” & “closing” in on itself (look at all the periods in this poem), & that as such the honest representation of troubled consciousness is more true than big, open-ended, transcendental language-gestures.


Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free